By Andrew B. Bindman, MD, Executive Vice President, Chief Medical Officer
A recent study found that housing instability was the factor most strongly associated with cancer mortality. Another showed that people with cancer who live in neighborhoods where healthy food is often expensive or hard to find are less likely to survive after surgery than those with easy access.
The research evidence is mounting to show that having a safe place to live, enough money to pay the bills, access to healthy meals, and meaningful social connections — factors that contribute to what we call social health — significantly impact health outcomes. Low-income populations, many of whom are disproportionately non-white, have more challenges meeting their social needs, which contributes to significant health disparities.
So why doesn’t the U.S. health care system address social health needs? In part because the approach to holding health plans and providers accountable for their performance is focused in the wrong place.
The goal of the health care system should be to maximize the health of the population by ensuring that every individual receives safe, equitable, and high-quality care. For more than 30 years, employers, government programs, and government regulators have tried to support that goal by requiring health care providers to report a common set of quality measures.
These measures have often focused on health care processes — such as whether a cancer screening was performed, or a prenatal appointment was scheduled — and not what is most meaningful to patients: their health outcomes. And for the most part, these measures have not been examined through the lens of equity.
Most health plans and providers have not captured and reported on the relationship between social factors and health because it can be challenging to create the infrastructure to do this effectively — especially for those without electronic health records and stable patient populations that can be tracked over time. And quite simply, it hasn’t been required.
At the same time, many health care organizations are adopting value-based care models that focus less on how much care is provided (fee-for-service-medicine) and instead emphasize the value that care delivers to the patient (often defined by better health outcomes).
It’s time for the U.S. health care system to rethink its approach — shifting to outcome measures, accounting for the role social factors play in those outcomes, and making these measures a required part of quality reporting. This will enable health care payers and providers to benchmark against one another and contribute to a shared understanding of how to improve outcomes by addressing both clinical and social needs.
At Kaiser Permanente, we’re already implementing methods to routinely measure health outcomes for significant clinical conditions, including cardiovascular disease, cancer, mental health and wellness, and maternal health. And we’re building our organizational capacity to sort and analyze our care outcomes by equity dimensions, such as race and ethnicity, to identify potential care gaps and create plans to correct them.
We are also regularly screening our members for social needs and integrating assessments directly into our electronic health records. This allows our clinicians to better connect members to community resources that support their ability to get or stay healthy. It also provides data to help us understand how these social care interventions, in combination with medical care, contribute to improved health outcomes.
These are important steps, and the impact we can have on the health of our communities can be enhanced by bringing others in the health care industry along with us.
The U.S. health care system is at a critical tipping point with several significant initiatives underway. For example, the National Committee for Quality Assurance recently announced that social needs screening and intervention will be a quality measure within the Healthcare Effectiveness Data and Information set for measurement year 2023. This measure will assess health plan members who were screened at least once during the measurement period for unmet food, housing, and transportation needs and who received a corresponding intervention if they screened positive. Other regulators are also developing ways to encourage health plans and providers to assess social factors, take action, and measure the results.
We at Kaiser Permanente support action in this direction and believe it will be most effective if regulators and other stakeholders across the health care system align on how these types of data will be collected and reported. Adopting common standards and definitions will reduce duplicative and potentially conflicting reporting requirements and help us to acquire knowledge more rapidly on how to meaningfully address inequities over time.
By working together, we can ensure the health care system is delivering care that provides the best possible outcomes for everyone.
Some of the most common conditions affecting men carry a social stigma …
Health care leaders and policymakers should each play their part to help …
One in 5 people experience depression, anxiety, or other mental health …
Black Americans experience worse health outcomes compared to other populations …
Greg A. Adams, chair and chief executive officer of Kaiser Permanente, …
Lynch syndrome is a gene mutation that increases colon cancer risk. Learn …
Virtual cardiac rehab helped Mike Kelly heal at home after a life-threatening …
A healthy life after cancer is possible. Learn how Kaiser Permanente helps …
Medical Financial Assistance program supports access to health care.
For Sam Beeson, having a midwife at her side during her pregnancy helped …
Learn more about a study to help prevent cancer.
Colorado musician back with the band thanks to new virtual cardiac rehab …
As part of the Cancer Screening Research Network, our researchers will …
A timely preventive test reveals Rebecca Kucera has cancer. Swift treatment …
Bill Coggins, who founded the Kaiser Permanente Watts Counseling and Learning …
Early detection of the disease, before it becomes advanced, will increase …
Kaiser Permanente physicians and medical students provide medical exams …
Screening for colorectal cancer is recommended for most people starting …
Care teams at Kaiser Permanente Fontana Medical Center helped Phillip Crawford …
Innovative surgical recovery program helps breast cancer patients safely …
The Kaiser Permanente Watts Counseling and Learning Center started as a …
Kaiser Permanente supports the ballot measure to expand and improve mental …
You have only one heart. ‘Prescribe’ yourself a few changes to help protect …
Kaiser Permanente opens medical offices and a new home for the Watts Counselin …
Research shows that marijuana use during pregnancy increases health risks …
One of the best ways to prevent future heart conditions is knowing what …
Tookie Gentilcore returns to enjoying life thanks to a quick, safe method …
Grateful for compassionate and successful Hodgkin lymphoma treatment at …
People with diabetes are more likely to have heart disease.
Kaiser Permanente’s Patient Advisory Councils help us create exceptional …
Cervical cancer is highly preventable. Learn how HPV vaccination and regular …
Kaiser Permanente celebrates inclusion at Special Olympics Southern California …
In Oregon, our stroke teams are providing patients with industry-leading …
Following a COVID-19-related hospital stay, Robert DeLeon took charge of …
Members experiencing a low risk pregnancy have the option of having their …
An unexpected cancer diagnosis left Jennifer Martin unsure of the next …
We offer housing-related legal help to prevent evictions and remove barriers …
Learn how you can participate in a study to uncover what causes cancer …
A new care option offers a mix of in-person and virtual visits, supported …
Steady employment can improve a person's health and well-being. Our new …
From diagnosis to recovery, David Parsons, MD, shares how screening, treatment …
Pavan Somusetty, MD, explains how people who need support and guidance …
Andrew B. Bindman, MD, is executive vice president and chief medical officer …
As a lifelong nonsmoker, Mariann Stephens was shocked to learn she had …
Dr. Yong Shin shares how people with heart disease can live longer, while …
The use of a ventricular assist device implant gives one Oregon woman the …
Our Advanced Care at Home program provides high-quality, safe care in familiar …
It’s never too late to quit smoking. At Kaiser Permanente, we can help …
To help develop talented, diverse community leaders, Kaiser Permanente …
In Oregon, specialists and parents come together to design a specialized …
A team of specialists treats an expecting mother’s cancer while keeping …
Joy Short, a Kaiser Permanente member and employee, turned her breast cancer …
Innovative medical-legal partnerships keep families in stable housing to …
Season 3 of “The Way Home” documentary series, created with support from …
For 75-year-old Peggy Dickston, a surprise diagnosis was caught early thanks …
Kaiser Permanente’s partnership with Fontana Unified School District brings …
The next phase for the Kaiser Permanente Center for Gun Violence Research …
Leading U.S. disability organizations recognize Kaiser Permanente for supporti …
Our annual report shows how our dedicated employees and physicians provided …
Fit and focused, an Oregon father and runner rebounds after an aortic valve …
For years, serious heart attacks meant hours of weekly appointments. Now, …
Our health plans are again rated among the nation’s best for overall treatment …
Supporting housing to improve health
Excessive heat and pollution can increase your risk of experiencing dangerous …
Stories in the Department of Research & Evaluation 2022 Annual Report demonstr …
Research and clinical trials play a vital role in advancing cancer treatment …
Kaiser Permanente is at the forefront of cervical cancer research. Find …
A new location-based vaccine strategy by Kaiser Permanente was successful …
A Kaiser Permanente cardiologist shares advice on how to stay safe, what …
Mammograms can help detect breast cancer early, when it’s easier to treat. …
After a diagnosis for a rare type of blood cancer, Marla Marriott got high-qua …
The Kaiser Permanente Southern California 2022 Community Health Snapshot …
Harold Newman had advanced prostate cancer. Genetic testing helped expand …
Learn how lifestyle medicine is part of cancer care at Kaiser Permanente.
For the third year in a row, every Kaiser Permanente hospital earned ‘high …
The Kaiser Permanente Community Support Hub can help members find community …
The Kaiser Permanente and 211 LA partnership makes strides in improving …
Fay Gordon's breast cancer was caught in the early stages thanks to genetic …
Chemotherapy can be an option during pregnancy. Find out how Kaiser Permanente …
Michael West shares his incredible journey from diagnosis to treatment …
A Kaiser Permanente plastic surgeon explains breast reconstruction options …
Many people with cancer experience depression and anxiety. Mental health …
Our members are more likely to feed their babies breast milk. And they’re …
After they were both diagnosed with colon cancer, Miguel and Paula fought …
Linda Tapia lives a healthy, active life, so she was stunned to be diagnosed …
Kaiser Permanente Los Angeles Medical Center’s Bridge Program has become …
Age, family history, and race are key factors.
Doctor and mother of 3 Susan Brim received top-notch care after her lung …
Kaiser Permanente addresses the Supreme Court decision on LGBTQIA+ protections …
Kaiser Permanente addresses the Supreme Court decision on affirmative action …
Kaiser Permanente celebrated its sixth year as official health partner …
Carter Shaver from Portland, Oregon, shares his optimistic smile after …
Help change the future of cancer prevention by joining Connect today.
A new study compares Kaiser Permanente members in Southern California to …
Take time to adjust to a new baby and lifestyle changes — and reach out …
Tips for preventing sunburn and decreasing the risk of skin cancer.
A reminder that men and women can assert control over risk factors that …
Thanks to personalized care from a team of skilled doctors, Christina McAmis …
The Achievable Foundation recognized Kaiser Permanente for its work to …
New climate collaborative with BSR announced at joint Kaiser Permanente …