Analysis compared outpatient contacts between March 9 and May 31, 2020.
PRESS RELEASE
Contacts: Jan Greene
janice.x.greene@kp.org
510-504-2663
Kerry Sinclair
ksinclair@webershandwick.com
310-854-8278
OAKLAND, Calif. — A detailed analysis of mental health treatment trends during the COVID-19 pandemic found a 7% increase in visits during the initial shelter-in-place period in 2020, compared with the same 3-month period in 2019.
The study, published in The Journal of Clinical Psychiatry March 3, examined patient visits for psychiatric diagnoses among members of Kaiser Permanente in Northern California.
The greatest increases in visits were for substance use (up 51%), adjustment disorder (up 15%), anxiety (up 12%), bipolar disorder (up 9%), and psychotic disorder (up 6%). Adjustment disorder is diagnosed when someone responds to a stressful life event with symptoms such as sadness and hopelessness.
“The increases we found in patients seeking care for substance use and anxiety are consistent with other data showing the pandemic and shelter-in-place orders were difficult for many people,” said lead author Kathryn Erickson-Ridout, MD, PhD, a psychiatrist with Kaiser Permanente in Northern California and a member of the Physician Researcher Program with the Kaiser Permanente Northern California Division of Research. “These findings reflect what I experienced with my patients who sought out care.”
The analysis focused on a period when Kaiser Permanente pivoted to virtual visits by video and telephone to ensure that patients continued to have access to care when shelter-in-place orders were implemented. “COVID-19 has created huge psychosocial disruption,” Dr. Erickson-Ridout said. “It’s impacting people’s ability to work, socialize, and have relationships, and that is having mental health consequences. We were able to respond to that with a robust telehealth system, to reach those patients and give them good care.”
The study was a retrospective observational analysis comparing 165,696 psychiatric outpatient contacts between March 9 and May 31, 2019, with 181,015 during the same period in 2020, an increase of 7%. The researchers also confirmed the shift away from in-person visits, tallying a 264% increase in telephone and video visits from the year before. Kaiser Permanente clinicians also offer mental health support by secure email message, but this study did not count those.
The study found 42% more addiction clinic visits than the same period in 2019. This could be related to patients having more difficulty coping with the pandemic, but it could also reflect existing patients having good connections with their addiction medicine providers, said study senior author Esti Iturralde, PhD, a research scientist with the Division of Research. “They may have been able to seek care more easily from the health system because of the strong connections and supports Kaiser Permanente provides, including case management,” she said.
The results also suggest some people did not immediately adjust to the new virtual visit format. Visits with new patients declined by 42%, as did visits by children and adolescents (down 23%), and older adults (down more than 5%).
The authors said these results may reflect which patients were most comfortable reaching out for telehealth care, at least during the first few months of the pandemic. Reliance on caregivers to facilitate visits, or healthcare avoidance during this time, may be behind these changes. Future research may reflect how patients adjusted to virtual visits past May 2020.
To increase use of virtual visits by these groups, and people with new mental health symptoms, the authors suggested outreach through collaborative care, such as getting referrals from primary care providers and other clinicians patients see for physical health concerns.
The research was supported by The Permanente Medical Group Delivery Science and Applied Research Initiative and Physician Researcher Program.
Other coauthors were Constance Weisner, DrPH, MSW, Cynthia Campbell, PhD, MPH, and Mubarika Alavi, MS, of the Division of Research; Samuel J. Ridout, MD, PhD, Maria T. Koshy, MD, Inderpreet Dhillon, MD, and Sameer Awsare, MD, of The Permanente Medical Group; and Brooke Harris, PhD, of the Kaiser Permanente Oakland Medical Center.
Kaiser Permanente is committed to helping shape the future of health care. We are recognized as one of America’s leading health care providers and not-for-profit health plans. Founded in 1945, Kaiser Permanente has a mission to provide high-quality, affordable health care services and to improve the health of our members and the communities we serve. We currently serve 12.4 million members in 8 states and the District of Columbia. Care for members and patients is focused on their total health and guided by their personal Permanente Medical Group physicians, specialists, and team of caregivers. Our expert and caring medical teams are empowered and supported by industry-leading technology advances and tools for health promotion, disease prevention, state-of-the-art care delivery, and world-class chronic disease management. Kaiser Permanente is dedicated to care innovations, clinical research, health education, and the support of community health.
Our investment in the Watts neighborhood of California, in partnership …
The Kaiser Permanente Colorado Health Action Summit gathered nonprofits, …
A Kaiser Permanente doctor shares key details. By learning more about autism, …
Funding from Kaiser Permanente in Washington helps to promote mental health, …
Behavioral health consultants can provide a better understanding of often …
Feeling emotional or overwhelmed after a new baby’s arrival? You’re not …
After a lifetime of feeling isolated, Moth Wygal finds connection thanks …
Naomi Girma, a sports ambassador for Kaiser Permanente, is passionate about …
One in 5 people experience depression, anxiety, or other mental health …
Gabriel Abarca had no hope for his future. Then the team at Kaiser Permanente …
The Kaiser Permanente Watts Counseling and Learning Center started as a …
Kaiser Permanente supports the ballot measure to expand and improve mental …
You have only one heart. ‘Prescribe’ yourself a few changes to help protect …
Kaiser Permanente opens medical offices and a new home for the Watts Counselin …
Supporting behavioral and mental health in communities where needs are …
Grateful for compassionate and successful Hodgkin lymphoma treatment at …
Everyday Health
Better public policies can help address the challenges. We encourage policymak …
There aren’t enough mental health professionals in the U.S. to meet the …
We offer housing-related legal help to prevent evictions and remove barriers …
Pavan Somusetty, MD, explains how people who need support and guidance …
Six steps help you prep for winter trips.
A child and adolescent psychiatrist shares tips on supporting your child …
Kaiser Permanente’s partnership with Fontana Unified School District brings …
Use biofeedback to help manage stress.
Former Major League Baseball player Drew Robinson shares his story of hope …
San Diego Wave Fútbol Club star defender Naomi Girma, Kaiser Permanente …
Our clinicians help patients get the care they need to move forward with …
Kaiser Permanente increases access to mental health services in Southern …
Expanding access to high-quality mental health services
These tips from Don Mordecai, MD, Kaiser Permanente’s national mental health …
Learn how lifestyle medicine is part of cancer care at Kaiser Permanente.
Many people with cancer experience depression and anxiety. Mental health …
Unique challenges and societal pressures can impact men’s emotional well-being …
Kaiser Permanente and the San Diego Wave Fútbol Club host a second Wave …
Kaiser Permanente is here to help with care and valuable tools to support …
Take time to adjust to a new baby and lifestyle changes — and reach out …
Shared experience helps young people in Oregon build confidence for their …
Creating a healthy relationship with social media can help safeguard the …
A Kaiser Permanente member shares his personal journey of navigating bipolar …
Changing my career and becoming a therapist revealed ways our country can …
Susan Sandhu struggled to find meaning in her life after an injury forced …
Trauma-informed outreach efforts in Orange County are being recognized …
Expanded access to high-quality, affordable mental health care supports …
Child psychiatrist defines anxiety, its symptoms, how to address it, and …
Kaiser Permanente’s partnership with Special Olympics Southern California …
Treatment for bipolar disorder and opiate addiction helps a Kaiser Permanente …
Southern California psychiatrist offers practical advice for parents to …
Kaiser Permanente in Southern California partners with San Diego Wave Fútbol …
Kaiser Permanente provides members with convenient ways to improve their …
A sleep expert shares 4 practical tips for coping with the time shift and …
Project Nurture in Portland, Oregon, provides treatment and a path forward …
Expert shares 5 valuable tips for parents and guardians to help children …
Valerie Dionne wins our 2023 George Halvorson Community Health Leadership …
Kaiser Permanente invests $3.3 million to build healthy social connections …
A Kaiser Permanente psychiatrist shares advice for coping when stress won't …
Why paint yourself into a corner with a resolution you’re half-hearted …
Find addiction and recovery information, assessments, and ways to get support …
Experience the best of the season by following these tips from an adult, …
A behavioral health consultant in Portland, Oregon, shares how mindfulness …
To meaningfully improve health equity, we must shift our focus to outcomes …
What you eat can impact your mental health.
Explore fresh ways to get motivated and incorporate wellness into your …
Recognizing the warning signs associated with suicide can help save lives. …
Support, talk about, and advocate for kids’ mental health. Otherwise, greater …
When someone you care about is struggling, it can be hard to know what …
A sports medicine physician and mental health therapist discuss the mind-body …
A child leaving home for the first time can cause parents feelings of both …
We reflect on 3 major COVID-19 surges, urgent vaccination efforts, and …
By reaching out early and providing care that’s personalized to parents’ …
A Kaiser Permanente radiation oncologist shares how giving patients a voice …
At our school of medicine, future doctors learn that to better treat patients …
In a new documentary, more than 20 young people share their stories: how …
An innovative telehealth program gives patients direct access to pharmacists …
A $60,000 grant will support the assessment of social-emotional health, …
Kaiser Permanente’s new Center for Gun Violence Research and Education …
He needed help coping with back pain while ending his reliance on opioids. …
Stress can easily become anger. But you can practice self-care to head …
A Kaiser Permanente physician shares new research and advice for the leading …
We must do more to prevent gun violence and educate on its health implications …
Las conversaciones honestas ayudan a que los jóvenes se sientan seguros …
Trusted conversations help youth feel safe when community violence occurs.
A community program dedicated to helping schools and districts meet the …
Newly released results show the Presence of Mind initiative can be an effectiv …
As overdose deaths skyrocket, an addiction medicine specialist explains …
NBA player Onyeka Okongwu and his mother, Kate, a Kaiser Permanente nurse, …
We applaud President Biden and Congress as they begin to set policies that …
A recent survey shows that many people are turning to online wellness tools …
Assessment helps parents and caregivers intervene early when kids are at …
Two years into the COVID-19 pandemic, a Kaiser Permanente pediatrician …
Stuck at home during the pandemic, a Kaiser Permanente member with autoimmune …
Guidance to help parents understand when moodiness is a normal part of …
A good night’s rest provides mental and physical benefits. Take advantage …
What you eat affects how you feel, both physically and emotionally. Here …
Don Mordecai, MD, Kaiser Permanente’s national leader for mental health …
Helping people strengthen connections, maintain healthy routines, and find …